The Indian equity market has consolidated at higher levels after bottoming out at around 15,300 on the Nifty in June 2022. Our economy is on the recovery path and global commodity prices are showing signs of cooling off. US inflation data in July was lower than June, after rising for 25 consecutive months. The market took the US July inflation data as a signal that inflation is cooling, raising hopes that we are reaching the end of the interest rate tightening cycle in the US. However, concerns about the US economy seem to be an overhang on the market at higher levels; over the past few days, we saw profit booking at around 18,000 levels on the Nifty.
Concerns of recession in the US
For the last 12 months US inflation rate has been above 5%, well above the US Federal Reserve’s long term target inflation rate of 2%. US inflation reached a 40 year high of 9.1% in June. The Fed has hiked interest rates by 2.25% so far. In his speech last Friday, Fed Governor Jerome Powell indicated that “some economic pain is on the horizon”. What does the Fed Governor mean by “economic pain” because the US GDP contracted by 1.6% in Q1 and by 0.6% in Q2. Two consecutive quarters of economic contraction indicates recession, but the US labour markets have remained strong; 528,000 new jobs were added in July despite economic slowdown. Average hourly wages increased 0.5% in July after gaining 0.4% in June (source: Reuters). Some analysts are interpreting Governor Powell’s “economic pain” comment as increase in unemployment in the US. The Fed Governors comment has been an overhang on the market for the last few days. US markets have corrected and we have seen profit booking in the Nifty at around 18,000 levels.
Scenarios of recession in the US
Historical data shows that recession in the US has impact on the Indian market, irrespective of how our economy performed. The question is what kind of recession will we see in the US? Earlier in this year, three scenarios were being discussed with regards to the US economy at the end of the interest rate cycle.
While the scenario of soft landing should not be ruled out because both US labour market and consumer spending still continues to be strong, let us consider the other two scenarios. Will we see a mild recession or a severe recession? The consensus view in Wall Street is that US will experience a mild recession in 2023. The view is that after hiking rates well into the first quarter of 2023, the Fed will start cutting interest rates towards the end of that year.
S&P 500 drawdown
Let us now look at the biggest drawdowns in S&P 500 over the last 20 years (as on 1st Sep 2022). You can see that despite the severity of the recession, the drawdown in the market is fairly short though the correction may be quite deep. The worst recession in the last 80 years was the Global Financial crisis of 2008, but the fall from peak to bottom took 17 months. The other two drawdowns last for 13 months and just 2 months.
We think that the length of drawdowns in future recessions will be short because the central banks and Governments quickly take steps to provide liquidity in financial markets along with fiscal stimulus to prevent large scale unemployment. We saw this in 2008 and even more aggressively during COVID-19. The market responds to the actions taken by central banks / Governments and bounce back from bottoms. Therefore, investors should be patient during bear markets because they do not last very long.
How Nifty bounced back from corrections?
We will now look at how the Nifty bounced back from corrections caused by US recessions over the last 20 years or so. You can see that length of drawdown in Nifty has not only been fairly short (maximum 10 months in the last 20 years) the market bounced back very strongly from all recessions. The bounce back in Nifty has often been much stronger than the bounce back in the US markets – all the more reason for investors to remain disciplined during market corrections. Historical data shows that highest wealth creation is made from investments in bear markets.
Why equities look good for the next few years?
What should investors do?